Wow! It's really amazing what passes for fact and knowledge these days, particularly in the medical community. Particularly when "fact and knowledge" are often funded by major drug companies that have a stake in the outcomes of these studies. It's not likely they are going to fund a study that has any chance of disproving an expected outcome!
The fact is, this study had no controlled clinical trials, it was based entirely on questionnaire responses, and had numerous adjustments to the data set. It's mentally painful to watch as medical researchers continue to espouse their theories on health as it relates to diet, only to observe that the "mainstream medical" dietary guidelines recommended to us for the last 40 years have actually made us more obese and sicker!
Actually, we've been doing what medical researchers have been saying to do for the last 40 years: our fat intake since the 1960s has actually dropped from 45 percent of total calories to less than 35 percent! So, we have been listening. Yet, in this time, obesity rates have doubled, and Type 2 diabetes rates have kept pace. From 1980 to 2004, obesity rates in adults have gone from 12-14 percent of the population to over 30 percent. But, we're all doing what the medical community is recommending, right? Less saturated fat, more whole grains, and MORE EXERCISE, right?
So, why can't I lose weight and keep it off?
Why do I continue to see cholesterol/hypertension/weight loss type drugs being constantly recommended?
American Heart Association statistics show that between 1973, and 2003, the number of inpatient medical procedures for heart disease increased 470 percent!
The short story is this, humans have been hunter/gatherers successfully evolving for about 2 million years on a diet of largely meats, eggs, fruits, and vegetables -- essentially what was available to them. Prior to even 100 years ago, there did not exist the preponderance of "modern diseases": heart disease, cancer, diabetes, that exist today.
So, how is it that nearly 2 million years of evidence with a very large sample size becomes disregarded by small research teams with purportedly a vast knowledge of statistics, research methodology, data collection methods, and observation tools? Follow the money. A lot, if not most, major published research is funded by a company, or a group with a stake in its outcome. In the editorial by Dr. Dean Ornish that accompanies this article, Dr. Ornish references a study done on rats that were fed high-fat, high-protein, low-carbohydrate (HPLC) diets. The study summary implied that this diet causes atherosclerotic plaques. It was funded by Unilever. So much for data bias. It's clear that Dr. Ornish also has a "personal interest" in the matter in his belief that the over-abundance of livestock in the world is killing us by contributing to the greenhouse gas effect.
In summary, Wellness as a business model doesn't pay. Drugs and treatment programs do. As long as the medical community continues to be supported, influenced and educated by Big Pharmacy, we will always have a backward approach to pragmatic health care.
No comments:
Post a Comment